Why Do Wolves Howl? Pack Mates, Rivals, and the Moon Myth

Wood-engraving of a wolf howling on a snowy ledge before a full moon, a second wolf howling on a far cliff, in ivory on black.

Wolves howl to keep in touch across distances too wide to see. A howl tells scattered pack mates where the others are, gathers a pack before it sets out to hunt, calls after a companion who has gone missing, and warns a neighboring pack away from a kill or a litter of pups. Each wolf's voice is distinct, so a howl also says who is calling. Wolves do not howl at the moon. They lift their muzzles to howl and are often awake after dark, which is probably where the picture comes from.

The reasons overlap. Biologists have separated them by recording who howls, when, and who answers.

Why do wolves howl?

Reason What researchers found
Finding pack mates out of sight In Poland, 43% of spontaneous howls passed between pack mates who had split up, and 18% came right after they met again.
Setting out to hunt Another 22% of those Polish howls came just before the pack left to hunt.
Calling a missing companion Captive wolves in Austria howled most for a close companion who had been led away.
Warning off other packs Minnesota packs answered imitation howls most often at a kill or with pups nearby.
Reacting to a disturbance In Yellowstone, people, bears, vehicles and strange wolves were among the most consistent triggers.

Wolves do not howl every time one of these things happens. In Yellowstone, ecologists John and Mary Theberge listed 22 social and environmental situations in which wolves howl, and found the howling inconsistent in most of them. A pack about to move may howl first, or one wolf after another may simply get up and walk off in silence. The Theberges also note that for wolves, howling is probably secondary to scent.

Do wolves howl when they miss each other?

Captive wolves do. In a 2013 experiment at the Wolf Science Center in Austria, researchers took one wolf at a time away from its pack for a 45-minute walk, testing nine wolves from two packs. The wolves left behind howled in 26 of 27 trials. When the same wolf was only moved to a neighboring enclosure, out of sight but somewhere the others knew, they howled in just two trials.

The pack howled more when the wolf led away ranked higher, and more when it was a close companion of the howler. Counting only the howls that started on their own, rather than answers to another wolf, closeness still predicted howling and rank did not. The team also measured cortisol, a stress hormone, in the saliva of the wolves that stayed. It was higher during the walks than in the control trials, but within the walks it did not predict how much a wolf howled. Mazzini and colleagues concluded that howling is not simply a stress reaction and that wolves seem to use it with some control, to stay in contact with the animals that matter to them. Nine captive wolves are a small sample, so the result shows what wolves are capable of more than how often wild packs do it.

How do wolves use howling against other packs?

Howling helps neighboring packs keep out of each other's way. Over two years in Minnesota's Superior National Forest, Fred Harrington and L. David Mech howled at radio-collared wolves from eight packs and ten lone wolves and recorded who answered. Packs replied most often at a kill, and the more food left on the carcass, the more often they answered. Packs with pups and larger packs also replied more. Lone wolves without territories rarely answered at all, which the authors read as the low profile you would expect from animals with no ground of their own.

They concluded that howling and scent marking do different jobs: a scent mark lasts and stays where it was left, while a howl is immediate and carries far. Howling seemed most useful when two packs were heading into an area where their territories overlapped, and when a pack came back to ground it had not used for weeks, after its old scent marks had lost their force.

Most howling still stays inside the family. In Poland, Nowak and colleagues found that only 2% of spontaneous howls seemed aimed at a neighboring pack. Yet in August, wolves there answered a human imitation 39% of the time.

Howling can also give a pack away. In their account for the National Park Service, the Theberges describe a Yellowstone pack that howled again and again while it was split by a busy park road, well outside its usual territory and on land claimed by another pack. Several days later the resident pack attacked and killed its well-known male, wolf 302. They write that they have seen howling lead to several other wolf deaths.

Can wolves recognize each other's howls?

Yes, as far as anyone can test it. Work with captive wolves in the 1960s found that wolves can tell apart the harmonic overtones in each other's howls, which makes recognition possible at a distance. The same work found that an excited wolf howls at a higher pitch. Computers can now do the sorting too. A 2021 study of Indian wolves trained a classifier on 49 howls from five wolves and identified them with 98% accuracy, then assigned 20 new howls from four other wolves correctly 75% of the time. The goal was to count wolves by their voices, without collars or cameras.

Wolves also sound different from one kind to the next. A 2016 study led by Arik Kershenbaum at Cambridge used computer algorithms to sort about 2,000 howls from wolves, coyotes and domestic dogs into 21 types. Each species and each wolf subspecies used those types in its own proportions, which Kershenbaum compared to a dialect. Timber wolves lean on low, flat howls. The critically endangered red wolf most often uses a high, looping one.

How far can a wolf howl be heard?

A wolf howl is loud and low, and the Indian wolf study gives a cautious figure: detectable at more than 6 kilometers, close to four miles. The National Park Service keeps a recording of wolves howling in Denali if you want to hear what carries that far.

Counting the wolves in a chorus is harder. In Minnesota, Harrington found that choruses lasted about a minute on average whatever the size of the pack, and that a pair of adults sounded much like a larger pack with pups. Each chorus began with plain howls that grew more modulated as it went on. He suggested the chorus may have evolved to make a small pack sound bigger, a bluff biologists call the Beau Geste effect. Polish recordings disagree on length: there, replies from one or two wolves lasted 34 to 40 seconds on average, those from five to seven wolves, pups included, 67 to 95 seconds, and the longest ran close to four minutes.

People listening in the field have the same trouble. Counting by ear commonly breaks down past three wolves, according to a 2015 study from Tuscany. Reading the recordings as spectrograms identified the size of 92% of 29 choruses whose size was already known.

When do wolves howl the most?

In the evening, and more in some seasons than others. In Poland's Białowieża Forest, spontaneous howling peaked between 6 p.m. and midnight, the hours of the wolves' evening peak in travel, and 58% of a year's spontaneous howls came between July and October, with a peak in August. That is when packs center their activity on the sites where they keep their pups, which is also why howling surveys run in summer.

Yellowstone shows a winter peak. Working from more than 11,000 howls logged over ten years by Rick McIntyre of the Yellowstone Wolf Project, the Theberges found that wolves howled four times as often in February as in May, on a yearly curve that follows the rise and fall of the wolves' reproductive hormones. Answers from foreign wolves increased from October through February. During denning and summer, almost every answer came from a pack mate. Harrington and Mech saw two peaks in Minnesota reply rates: a midwinter rise tied to the breeding season, and a longer one that crested around August. The Polish and Yellowstone records count howls in different ways, so their peaks are not directly comparable.

Why do wolves howl at the moon?

They don't. The studies above tie howling to the hour, the season, the breeding cycle, a kill, a litter, an intruder or a missing companion, and none of them names the moon as a cause. Krista Woerheide of the International Wolf Center says wolves are "howling to talk to each other", to their own pack or to wolves outside it.

The picture has two easy sources. A howling wolf lifts its muzzle, so in silhouette it seems to be speaking to the sky. And wolves are busiest in dim light. A radio-tracking study in Białowieża Forest found that wolves killed more prey than expected in dim light, at dawn, at dusk and on moonlit nights, and the authors suggest dim light gives them their best chance at prey. A wolf that is up and moving at night will sometimes howl while the moon happens to be up. The werewolf's monthly full-moon rule is a separate story, and a much younger one than the old transformation tales.

January's full moon is still called the Wolf Moon. The Old Farmer's Almanac says the name is thought to come from wolves being more likely to be heard howling then, and it now rejects the old idea that they howled from hunger. The season fits the field records. Minnesota wolves answered more in midwinter, and Yellowstone's howling builds toward a February high.

From the archive

For the moon and the howl together, Howling Wolf: Lunar Cycle sets a howling head inside a ring of moon phases. Gray Wolf Field Guide is an engraved plate whose small scenes include a wolf howling at dusk, and Wolf Moon: The Hanging Skull puts three wolves among standing stones under a full moon.

Sources

Filed under: Field Notes, Folklore